Is an Annuity a Good Idea if You Don’t Have High Net Worth?

Illustration of a person assessing a financial shield in a home setting, representing the search for the right annuity fit. — A woman holds a glowing shield-shaped puzzle piece, illustrating how the right financial security fits into your retirement plan.

Are Annuities the Right Fit for You?

This is often seen as a good way to get a steady income in retirement, and it can seem expensive. It’s true that some annuities, like the ones that guarantee lifetime income, need a big upfront investment, but there are more affordable options. Deferred annuities, for example, might work for people with less wealth.

Annuities come with a risk for everyone, regardless of how much money you have. We talk about high fees and limited access to your cash; however, we’re going to explain in this article how annuities work and the different ways to fund them, as well as whether they are a good option for people with smaller savings.

annuity — Photo by Ground Picture from Shutterstock

Let’s understand annuities.

Before you make a decision, let’s understand how annuities work. They are paid with a large lump sum or even smaller payments over time, and in return, you get a regular income, right away or in the future.

There are 2 different types of annuities based on when you get the payment.

Immediate annuities: They start paying off within one year after you buy them. How much you will get depends on your age, your investment, and the type of annuity. Immediate annuities usually come with a bit of upfront payment.

Deferred annuities: They start paying after a longer time, often in retirement. You can let your investment grow over time by making smaller payments.

Is it worth buying an annuity if you don’t have a high net worth?

Annuities are helpful for people with high net worth, and they provide guaranteed income, tax benefits, and protection from market ups and downs, so retirement planning becomes more secure.

For people who have lower net worths, it’s important to put the benefits and the risks in balance. An annuity can offer you a steady income in retirement, but it can also drain your savings and might leave you unprepared for some unexpected expenses. Once you start receiving payments, it’s hard to access your money, and withdrawing early usually comes with penalties.

Most of the time, annuities require a large upfront payment, and this is not a practical thing for everyone. If you don’t have a few hundred thousand dollars, it may not be the best option to get annuities. Certified financial planners suggest that people with less savings can benefit more from keeping their money in a flexible portfolio.

Experts advise that putting money, no more than 25-30% of your net worth, into an immediate annuity if your net worth is $500,000 or higher makes more sense.

For lower net worths, deferred annuities can better fit, and they are more accessible and rentable if you let them grow over time.

A horizontal diagram comparing the payment structures of immediate and deferred annuities with net worth recommendations. — This diagram illustrates how deferred annuities allow assets to compound over time before providing future income.

Are deferred annuities a good option?

They seem like a more accessible choice, but many financial advisors don’t see them as a strong alternative to immediate annuities. They say it’s not a good idea to lock in lifetime income terms without knowing future inflation rates, as this is a risky thing to do.

Deferred variable and indexed annuities can protect you from losses, but they can also limit your potential earnings. People with less wealth are suggested to explore better ways to grow and manage their finances, and these are some options:

401(k) Plans—if your employer offers this possibility, that’s a great way to grow your savings. You have control over your money, and many employers can provide matching contributions, which is basically free money in your retirement.

Roth IRA – this lets you withdraw your savings tax-free in retirement and offers a wide range of investment possibilities, like stocks, ETFs, and bonds. You can choose to open one with minimum requirements and avoid ongoing account fees.

Even if they seem to be a more affordable option, it’s not like they are without flaws. Many advisors are cautious about them, and, for example, they find it unappealing to lock in lifetime income terms without knowing how inflation can impact the future. Some of them, like the variable or indexed ones, promise some sort of protection from market losses, but there are limits that can cap your potential gains. People who have less wealth can find better ways to make the most of their situation. Annuities are sold by agents who earn commissions or brokers, so they might try to sell to you even if it’s not the best option.

A paper-craft collage showing a grey umbrella protecting a golden nest egg from jagged red lines. — A black umbrella labeled guaranteed income shelters golden eggs from the surrounding market ups and downs.

Annuities are not absolutely horrible, so let’s see their benefits:

Deferred annuities, which are also called accumulation annuities, can offer some advantages: You will have a guaranteed income, as they provide a steady income, especially helpful if you’re worried about your retirement years.

Tax-deferred growth is another benefit, which means you won’t pay taxes on earnings until you start receiving money or withdraw. There is some market protection, as fixed annuities can shield your savings from ups and downs by offering a set rate in return.

A collage featuring a locked glass jar containing money, surrounded by sharp orange shapes representing fees. — A rusty lock secures a jar of money, highlighting the potential for high fees and withdrawal penalties.

Drawbacks

Annuities aren’t the best for everyone. They are complex, usually carry high fees, and limit access to your money. These are the downsides: These come with costs like administrative fees, surrender charges, and annual charges that can total 1-3% per year and cut into your returns. Once payouts start, it’s hard to change the terms and access your money without penalties. This is a big issue if you don’t have other savings for unexpected situations.

There is a risk of Low Returns because with fixed interest rates, and an investment that is underperforming, you can earn a lot less than if you’d choose to put your money into something else. Moreover, annuities are hard to understand with no good legal or financial expertise will lead to confusion or mistakes.

Is an annuity right for you?

This is a decision that depends on your financial situation, risk tolerance, and goals. If you have a high net worth and you want guaranteed income, an annuity can be a great addition to your retirement plan. If money is tight, on the other side, you better explore other options.

Don’t hesitate to talk with a financial advisor before deciding to buy an annuity and look for a fiduciary advisor who’s legally required to act in your best interest. Don’t go directly to the ones selling annuities because you might face a product push that won’t suit your needs. The best option is a fee-only advisor who can help you assess your finances and offer you guidance toward the best retirement strategy.

Bottom line, annuities can be useful for some, but they are not the only solution, and most of the time, not the best one. Weigh the pros and cons and consider getting professional advice before deciding if an annuity fits your long-term goals or if you better go for something less complicated and more secure, finding your needs in the best way.

Start 2025 on the right track with this budget planner! Order it on Amazon and take control of your finances.

If you found our article useful, read this one next: 12 Money Secrets from Donald Trump